Exercise 1.1
1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful.
5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
Exercise 1.2
a. He might be like a madman.
b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs.
c. He imagines he is dreaming.
d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses.
e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time.
f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking.
g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him about objects they cannot perceive clearly.
h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious concepts, such as simple mathemtical truths.
i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths.
j. His dreams must be copies of something real.
此Blog是中正大學九十九年度第一學期哲學系【史賓諾沙論上帝與心靈】的網路平台，此課程由教育部中綱計畫「經典教學計畫」補助,計畫編號MOE-099-01-02-2-11-2-15 ○授課教授：侯維之老師●上課時間：[星期四]十點十分至十二點○助教：胡映群●上課地點：文學院140室
請問是要排編號內容在文本上出現的順序嗎?
回覆刪除ps.要發意見似乎要先辦一個google帳號
許同學 不好意思
回覆刪除作業第二題是要編號a,b,c,..在meditation I上出現的順序
以下是分組討論網路作業的使用方式:
1. 進入http://lockedescartes.blogspot.com/2009/10/meditation-i-homework.html#comments
2. 在張貼意見方框中 寫入你/妳對這次分組討論題目的想法
3. 在『發表意見的身分』選取 名稱『網址』
4. 『名稱』打入你/妳的姓名 網址部分可以空著不打
5. 最後滑鼠點選『張貼意見』
-----
助教:找不到你gmail的信箱,只有yahoo的信箱.
回覆刪除Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful.
5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
Ans:I.I.C.I.C.C
Exercise 1.2
a. He might be like a madman.
b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs.
c. He imagines he is dreaming.
d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses.
e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time.
f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking.
g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him about objects they cannot perceive clearly.
h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious concepts, such as simple mathemtical truths.
i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths.
j. His dreams must be copies of something real.
Ans:b→d→a→f→c→j→i→h→e→g
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除(I) 1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
(I) 2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
(C) 3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
(C) 4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful.
(C) 5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
(C) 6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
Exercise 1.2
a. He might be like a madman.
b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs.
c. He imagines he is dreaming.
d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses.
e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time.
f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking.
g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him about objects they cannot perceive clearly.
h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious concepts, such as simple mathemtical truths.
i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths.
j. His dreams must be copies of something real.
A：b→d→g→c→f→i→j→h→e→a
496125021 哲學三 洪志豪
回覆刪除Exercise 1.1
(I) 1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
(I) 2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
(C) 3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
(C) 4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful.
(C) 5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
(I) 6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
※題目寫：要區辨每個陳述是否和Meditation I首兩段一致(Consistent)。如果這裡的一致是指「可以同時為真」，那麼2和6都和Meditation I首兩段一致，因為Meditation I的首兩段裡沒有陳述與之相衝突；如果這裡的一致是指Meditation I首兩段「有提到的」，那麼Meditation I首兩段並沒有提到2和6。
Exercise 1.2
(1) b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs.
(2) d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses.
(3) g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him about objects they cannot perceive clearly.
(4) a. He might be like a madman.
(5) f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking.
(6) c. He imagines he is dreaming.
(7) j. His dreams must be copies of something real.
(8) i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths.
(9) h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious concepts, such as simple (1)mathemtical truths.
(10) e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time.
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除(I) 1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
(I) 2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
(C) 3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
(C) 4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful.
(C) 5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
(C) 6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
Exercise 1.2
a. He might be like a madman. 在Par. 4
b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs. 在Par. 1
c. He imagines he is dreaming. 在Par. 6第一句
d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses. 在Par. 3前
e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time. 在Par. 12
f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking. 在Par. 5
g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him 在Par. 3後
about objects they cannot perceive clearly.
h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious 在Par. 9
concepts, such as simple mathemtical truths.
i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths. 在Par. 8
j. His dreams must be copies of something real. 在Par. 6
順序:b>d>g>a>f>c>j>i>h>e
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除(I)(I)(C)(C)(I)(C)
Exercise 1.2
B→d→g→a→f→c→j→i→h→e
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除(I)1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
(I)2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
(C)3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
(C)4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful.
(C)5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
(C)6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
Exercise 1.2
a. He might be like a madman.
b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs.
c. He imagines he is dreaming.
d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses.
e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time.
f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking.
g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him about objects they cannot perceive clearly.
h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious concepts, such as simple mathemtical truths.
i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths.
j. His dreams must be copies of something real.
Ans: b-d-g-a-f-c-j-i-h-e
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful.
5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
Exercise 1.2
a. He might be like a madman.
b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs.
c. He imagines he is dreaming.
d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses.
e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time.
f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking.
g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him about objects they cannot perceive clearly.
h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious concepts, such as simple mathemtical truths.
i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths.
j. His dreams must be copies of something real.
1.1
1.c 2.c 3.c 4.i 5.i 6.i
1.2
b d g a c f h e
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除（Ｉ）1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
（Ｉ）2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
（Ｃ）3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
（Ｃ）4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful.
（Ｃ）5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
（Ｉ）6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
Exercise 1.2
（４）a. He might be like a madman.
（１）b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs.
（６）c. He imagines he is dreaming.
（２）d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses.
（10）e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time.
（５）f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking.
（３）g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him about objects they cannot perceive clearly.
（９）h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious concepts, such as simple mathemtical truths.
（８）i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths.
（７）j. His dreams must be copies of something real.
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除(I)1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
(I)2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
(C)3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
(C)4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful.
(C)5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
(C)6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
Exercise 1.2
(4)a. He might be like a madman.
(1)b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs.
(6)c. He imagines he is dreaming.
(2)d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses.
(10)e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time.
(5)f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking.
(3)g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him about objects they cannot perceive clearly.
(9)h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious concepts, such as simple mathemtical truths.
(8)i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths.
(7)j. His dreams must be copies of something real.
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除(I)1. He must show each of his beliefs to be
false.
(C)2. It is not possible to achieve certainty
about anything.
(I)3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky
foundation.
(C)4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly
doubtful the same as beliefs that are
completely doubtful.
(C)5. He will begin by attacking his
"foundational" beleifs.
(C)6. All knowledge appears to come through the
senses.
Exercise 1.2
b→d→g→a→c→f→j→i→h→e
a. He might be like a madman.
b. He needs to attack the foundations of his
beleifs.
c. He imagines he is dreaming.
d. He asserts that all he has learned has come
from his senses.
e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him
all the time.
f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming
from waking.
g. He remembers that his senses occasionally
deceive him about objects they cannot
perceive clearly.
h. He believes God might be deceiving him about
even obvious concepts, such as simple
mathemtical truths.
i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know
simple mathematical truths.
j. His dreams must be copies of something real.
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除(I ) 1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
(I ) 2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
(C) 3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
(C) 4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful.
(C) 5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
(C) 6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
Exercise 1.2
(4) a. He might be like a madman.
(1) b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs.
(5) c. He imagines he is dreaming.
(2) d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses.
(10) e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time.
(6) f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking.
(3) g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him about objects they cannot perceive clearly.
(9) h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious concepts, such as simple mathemtical truths.
(8) i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths.
(7) j. His dreams must be copies of something real.
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除(I)1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
(I)2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
(C)3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
(I)4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completelydoubtful.
(C)5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
(I)6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
Exercise 1.2
(3)a. He might be like a madman.
(1)b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs.
(5)c. He imagines he is dreaming.
(2)d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses.
(8)e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time.
(4)f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking.
(9)g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him about objects they cannot perceive clearly.
(10)h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious concepts, such as simple mathemtical truths.
(6)i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths.
(7)j. His dreams must be copies of something real.
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful.
5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
1.I
2.I
3.C
4.C
5.C
6.C
Exercise 1.2
a. He might be like a madman.
b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs.
c. He imagines he is dreaming.
d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses.
e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time.
f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking.
g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him about objects they cannot perceive clearly.
h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious concepts, such as simple mathemtical truths.
i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths.
j. His dreams must be copies of something real.
d
g
b
a
f
c
j
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful.
5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
Ans:I I C I C C
Exercise 1.2
Ans: b d g a c f h e
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除(C):consistent
(I):inconsistent
1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false. (I)
2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything. (I)
3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation. (C)
4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful. (C)
5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs. (C)
6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses. (I)
Exercise 1.2
a. He might be like a madman. 4
b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs. 1
c. He imagines he is dreaming. 6
d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses. 2
e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time. 10
f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking. 5
g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him about objects they cannot perceive clearly. 3
h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious concepts, such as simple mathemtical truths. 9
i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths. 8
j. His dreams must be copies of something real. 7
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除1. He must show each of his beliefs to be false.
2. It is not possible to achieve certainty about anything.
3. His beliefs have a doubtful, shaky foundation.
4. He should treat beliefs that are slightly doubtful the same as beliefs that are completely doubtful.
5. He will begin by attacking his "foundational" beleifs.
6. All knowledge appears to come through the senses.
1.I
2.I
3.C
4.C
5.C
6.C
Exercise 1.2
a. He might be like a madman.
b. He needs to attack the foundations of his beleifs.
c. He imagines he is dreaming.
d. He asserts that all he has learned has come from his senses.
e. He imagines an evil demon who is fooling him all the time.
f. He does not beleive he can tell dreaming from waking.
g. He remembers that his senses occasionally deceive him about objects they cannot perceive clearly.
h. He believes God might be deceiving him about even obvious concepts, such as simple mathemtical truths.
i. Whether he is asleep or awake, he can know simple mathematical truths.
j. His dreams must be copies of something real.
b>d>g>a>f>c>j>i>h>e
Exercise 1.1
回覆刪除1.I 2.I 3.C
4.C 5.C 6.I
Exercise 1.2
d→b→c→a→f→j→i→h→e→g